Companion Planting

What Not to Plant Near Tomatoes: Bad Companions and Why

Plants to keep away from tomatoes, including potatoes, corn, fennel, brassicas and black walnut, with the reason for each and how strong the evidence is.

On this page
  1. Potatoes
  2. Corn
  3. Fennel
  4. Brassicas
  5. Black walnut
  6. Blueberries
  7. Mature dill
  8. Squash, pumpkins and large melons
  9. How strong is the evidence?
  10. Planning beds around these plants

Most plants can share a garden with tomatoes, but a handful are widely advised against. Some compete hard for water and nutrients, some share diseases or pests, some block the light, and some release compounds that slow tomato growth. The evidence behind each warning varies, so this guide gives the reason for each one, along with how strong the case is.

The plants most often warned against are:

  • Potatoes
  • Corn
  • Fennel
  • Brassicas, including cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, kale, and Brussels sprouts
  • Black walnut
  • Blueberries
  • Mature dill
  • Large sprawling squash and melons

Potatoes

Potatoes are in the nightshade family, the same family as tomatoes. They share several diseases, including early blight and late blight, and some soil-borne wilt diseases. Growing them together makes it easier for these diseases to move between the two crops. Potatoes are also heavy feeders, so the two crops compete for nutrients. Keep potatoes and tomatoes out of the same bed, and rotate them to different parts of the garden each season.

Corn

Corn grows tall, and tomatoes need full sun to ripen their fruit well. Corn can shade them, which can slow growth and fruiting. Corn also shares a major pest with tomatoes: corn earworm, which is also called tomato fruitworm. The moths lay eggs on both crops, and the caterpillars feed on the fruit and kernels. Keep corn in its own bed, away from the tomatoes.

Fennel

Fennel is the warning gardeners give most often. It is widely reported to release compounds that inhibit the growth of nearby plants, and tomatoes are among the plants often named. Some research supports the idea that fennel’s compounds inhibit other plants, but the evidence for tomatoes specifically is mostly anecdotal. Keep fennel in its own bed or at the far edge of the garden as a precaution.

Brassicas

Cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, kale, and Brussels sprouts are heavy feeders with large root systems, and they compete with tomatoes for water and nutrients. This is most noticeable in small beds. Brassicas also grow best in cool weather, so their timing often doesn’t match the warm-season needs of tomatoes. The claim that brassicas stunt tomatoes is mostly anecdotal, but competition for water and nutrients is a reasonable concern. The simplest approach is a separate bed.

Black walnut

Black walnut trees (Juglans nigra) release a compound called juglone from their roots, leaves, and husks. Juglone harms many plants, and tomatoes are sensitive to it. Affected tomatoes can wilt and decline. Keep tomatoes well away from black walnut trees, and remember that the roots reach well beyond the canopy. Other walnuts can produce juglone too, so be cautious near any walnut tree.

Blueberries

Blueberries and tomatoes need different soil. Blueberries prefer acidic soil, roughly pH 4.5 to 5.5. Tomatoes grow best closer to neutral, roughly pH 6.0 to 6.8. At blueberry-friendly acidity, some nutrients that tomatoes need become less available. Their fertiliser needs also differ. Blueberries do best with fertilisers made for acid-loving plants, while tomatoes need a feed that’s relatively high in phosphorus and potassium once flowering starts. Grow them in separate beds or containers.

Mature dill

Young dill is a good companion for tomatoes, and it attracts beneficial insects when it’s allowed to flower. Once dill matures and sets seed, it’s widely reported to inhibit tomato growth. Many gardeners grow dill in a separate bed or container for this reason, which is a cheap precaution.

Squash, pumpkins and large melons

Winter squash, pumpkins, and large melons spread widely. Their vines can shade tomatoes, crowd the airflow around them, and smother lower stems. This is a problem of space more than chemistry. If you grow them near tomatoes, give each crop its own zone, and train the vines away from the tomatoes. Cucumbers are easier to fit in a shared bed; see cucumbers and tomatoes.

How strong is the evidence?

Some warnings are well founded. Potatoes share diseases with tomatoes, black walnut produces a compound that harms them, and blueberries need a different soil pH. Corn, brassicas, fennel, and mature dill are backed mainly by experience, with some research on fennel’s growth-inhibiting compounds. Gardeners do report growing some of these together without trouble, especially with generous spacing and good soil. When space is tight, keeping them apart is the safest choice.

Planning beds around these plants

Plan the beds before you plant. Keep potatoes and tomatoes apart, keep black walnut and blueberries well away, and group tomatoes with other vegetables that prefer near-neutral soil. Peppers and eggplant share some pests and diseases with tomatoes, but many gardeners grow them together with good spacing and rotation. For the wider picture, see companion plants for tomatoes.

The complete guide to companion planting

Companion Plants for Tomatoes
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →