Short answer
Any good-quality compost can grow tomatoes in a pot. The label, the structure of the mix and how you water matter more than the brand name. For longer seasons, a loam-based mix is often recommended. For most people, a multipurpose compost with a little added perlite or grit works well. For planting in beds instead, see the best soil for tomatoes in the ground.
What to look for on the bag
- Labelled for containers, tomatoes or multipurpose use. Check that the bag says what it is for, and avoid mixes sold only as seed compost, which are too fine and feed-poor for a fruiting plant.
- Loam-based mixes. John Innes No. 3 is a common example. Loam-based mixes are heavier, hold nutrients well and are often recommended for long-season container tomatoes. They cost more and are harder to move.
- Peat-free or peat-based. Read the label for the main ingredients, such as coir, wood fibre or bark. Both types can grow good tomatoes.
- Starter nutrients. Most composts contain a few weeks’ worth of feed. Plan to start feeding the plant once it begins to flower and set fruit. For a feeding plan, see how often to feed tomatoes in pots and containers.
Peat-free compost: the trade-offs
- Quality and consistency can vary between brands and between batches.
- Some peat-free mixes dry out and are slow to take water again once fully dry. Water slowly and thoroughly, and let the water soak in.
- Nutrient content and structure differ, so plan a feeding routine from early on.
- Many peat-free mixes grow good tomatoes when they are watered and fed to match.
How to judge compost quality
- Texture: even, crumbly and not sticky or waterlogged when you open the bag.
- Smell: earthy. A sour or rotten smell is a warning sign.
- Contents: few large sticks, stones or hard clumps.
- Label: the intended use, the main ingredients and any feed information.
- Trial: buy a small bag or a sample to test before committing to a large one.
Why we don’t rank individual brands
Brand reviews are a weak guide for compost. One batch can differ from the next, and a single grower’s results depend on their watering, pots and climate. We don’t test or rate brands here.
If you are comparing a specific product, such as Dalefoot, read the current label, compare its type and ingredients with other bags, and look for independent trials rather than a single review.
What the RHS recommends
The RHS has promoted peat-free growing for many years. Its advice on specific products changes over time, so check its current guidance before buying.
Making your own mix for pots
Start with a good multipurpose or loam-based compost, then mix in a small amount of perlite or grit to improve drainage. Mix it thoroughly before planting. If you use a slow-release tomato fertiliser, follow the label for how much to add at planting. For fertiliser options, see the best tomato feed and fertiliser.
Fill the pot with the mix, pressing it down gently to remove large air gaps without compacting it. Leave a few centimetres at the top for watering. For how the pot’s size affects watering, see how big pots need to be for tomatoes.
Old compost and spent plants
- Healthy spent plants can be chopped up and added to a compost heap.
- Plants with blight or other serious disease (see how to tell if your tomatoes have blight) should go in the household bin, not the compost heap, because disease can survive in plant material.
- Reusing compost: remove old roots and debris, mix in fresh compost, and plan a feed. Compost from a plant that had a serious disease should be replaced rather than reused for tomatoes.
Once the compost is in place, watering is the next thing to get right. See should tomatoes in pots be watered every day. If you are considering a planter with its own water reservoir, see self-watering planters for tomatoes.