Yes, for most people. Green tomatoes and the seeds inside them are generally safe to eat in normal amounts, and cooks have used them for generations in fried green tomatoes, pickles, and chutneys. Keep three points in mind: unripe tomatoes contain more of a natural compound called tomatine, the leaves and stems of the plant shouldn’t be eaten, and any fruit that’s moldy or rotting should be thrown out, whatever its color.
Why green tomatoes are different
Tomatoes naturally contain compounds called glycoalkaloids. The main one is tomatine. Unripe fruit contains more tomatine than ripe fruit, and the level falls as the tomato ripens. Tomatine also adds a bitter, astringent taste, which is one reason green tomatoes taste so different from ripe ones.
Potatoes are a common source of confusion. Potato skins and sprouts contain solanine, a different glycoalkaloid. Tomatoes contain tomatine instead, so the advice about green potatoes doesn’t carry over directly.
Are green tomatoes safe to eat?
For most people, yes, in normal amounts. How you eat them matters:
- Cooked. Frying, roasting, stewing, and baking are the most common ways people eat green tomatoes. Cooking is a reasonable choice, but treat it as a matter of moderation rather than a way to remove tomatine.
- Pickled or in relish. Pickles and chutneys often use acid, salt, and sugar, which change the flavor. They’re a traditional way to use unripe fruit.
- Raw. Green tomatoes are firm, sour, and astringent. A few slices in a sandwich or salad are a common choice for many people. Large amounts of raw unripe fruit aren’t a good idea, and some people find them hard on the stomach.
Are the seeds safe to eat?
Yes. Seeds are eaten along with the flesh in most raw and cooked uses, and you don’t need to remove them. Seeds in an unripe fruit are less developed and softer, but the same rule applies: if the fruit looks and smells sound, the seeds are fine to eat with it.
Is it normal for tomato seeds to be green?
Often, yes. The gel around the seeds can look green in some varieties even when the fruit is ripe. For varieties with unusual colors, see heirloom tomato varieties. A fruit picked early, or one that ripened under stress, can have green gel too. A green tinge usually reflects the variety or the stage of ripeness, and by itself it isn’t a sign of spoilage.
Plant parts to avoid
The fruit is the part people eat. The leaves, stems, and other green parts of the tomato plant contain higher levels of tomatine and aren’t meant for eating. Keep them away from young children and pets, who may nibble on them.
Signs a tomato should be thrown out
Color isn’t the test. Discard a tomato, green or red, if you see:
- Mold, fuzzy or otherwise
- Soft, slimy, or leaking spots
- A sour or fermented smell
- Deep cracks or insect damage with rot underneath (see why tomatoes split)
When in doubt, throw it out.
Using green tomatoes
Green tomatoes work well in fried green tomatoes, relish, chutney, pickles, pies, and sauces. If an unripe fruit won’t ripen on the vine, will a green tomato ripen if I pick it? explains what to expect after picking. If you’re saving seed from an unripe fruit, see can I save seeds from a green tomato?. For general harvest advice, see harvesting and using homegrown tomatoes.
If you have a health condition or concerns about a particular food, check with your doctor.