Heirloom tomatoes come in a huge range of colours, shapes and flavours, from large pink beefsteaks to striped, green and near-black fruit. The best-known varieties include Brandywine, Cherokee Purple, Black Krim, Green Zebra, Striped German and Amish Paste. They are grouped below by fruit type, with notes on how to grow them.
What makes a tomato an heirloom?
There is no official definition. Most people use the term for open-pollinated varieties that have been passed down for a long time, often at least 50 years. Open-pollinated means that seed saved from the plant should grow into plants much like the parent. That is different from F1 hybrids, which do not reliably come true from seed.
Tomatoes mostly pollinate themselves, so home gardeners rarely need to isolate plants to save seed, although insects can carry pollen between nearby varieties. See can you plant different tomatoes together.
Large beefsteak heirlooms
Brandywine comes in pink and red forms. It is a large, ribbed beefsteak with a rich, fruity, slightly tangy flavour. For more, see our Brandywine growing guide.
Amana Orange is a large orange beefsteak with a mild flavour. It is a good choice if you want a bright fruit for slicing.
German Johnson is a vigorous plant with potato-leaf foliage. Gardeners often praise its strong flavour.
Arkansas Traveler is a pink slicing tomato that copes well with heat and has a balanced flavour.
Purple, black and striped heirlooms
Cherokee Purple has dusky rose-purple skin, a deep brick-red interior and a rich, sweet, smoky flavour.
Black Krim is a dark reddish-purple tomato with a bold, smoky taste. Its name points to Crimea, where it is thought to have come from.
Green Zebra stays green with yellow-amber stripes when ripe, and it has a tangy flavour. Its colour does not change much as it ripens, so check for slight softness and a sweet smell rather than relying on colour. For more on judging ripeness, see harvesting and using homegrown tomatoes.
Striped German has yellow and red marbling and a fruity flavour.
Paste, cherry and small heirlooms
Amish Paste is a meaty heirloom paste tomato with few seeds. It suits sauces and slicing. See our guide to the best tomatoes for sauce.
Black Cherry is a small, dark cherry tomato with a sweet, savoury flavour. For more small types, see our best cherry tomato varieties.
Yellow Pear is a small, pear-shaped yellow tomato that crops heavily.
Growing heirlooms
Heirloom tomatoes often need more care than modern hybrids. Many are indeterminate, so they need strong stakes or cages. Some ripen more slowly, so check the season length before you choose. Many have little resistance to common diseases, so give them good airflow, avoid wetting the leaves, and rotate your beds. If blight is common where you grow, see blight-resistant tomato varieties.
Some heirloom beefsteaks are prone to cracking when watering is uneven. Keep the water steady, especially once fruit begins to form. See why tomatoes split.
To save seed, choose healthy, fully ripe fruit from a plant you want to continue. Dry the seed fully and store it cool and dry. Our Rouge de Marmande guide explains the method step by step.
Choosing heirlooms by use and season
Choose by how you plan to eat the fruit. Beefsteaks suit slicing and sandwiches, striped and dark types add colour to salads, paste types are best for sauce, and small cherry types are good for snacking.
Check the season length on the seed packet. Many heirlooms need a long, warm summer. If you garden somewhere cool, our guide to the best tomato varieties for the UK climate covers types that suit shorter seasons.
Names can differ between seed companies, and a single name can cover several forms. Pink and Red Brandywine, for example, are different forms of the same family. Read the description before you buy.