Beefsteak tomatoes are the big, meaty slicing types. They have thick flesh and are often ribbed, and one fruit can fill a burger or a thick sandwich. This guide covers the best-known heirloom and hybrid beefsteaks, how to choose between them and how to get big fruit to ripen.
What makes a tomato a beefsteak?
Beefsteak describes the type of fruit rather than a single variety. It means a large, thick-fleshed slicing tomato. Most beefsteaks are indeterminate vines that keep growing and fruiting through the season, so they need a long, warm summer and strong support.
Heirloom beefsteaks
Cherokee Purple has dusky purple-red fruit and a rich, deep, complex flavour. Many gardeners name it as a favourite for taste, though it can be tricky to grow and may be less productive than some other types.
Brandywine is a classic pink heirloom with large, ribbed fruit and a sweet, complex flavour. Our Brandywine growing guide covers its care in detail.
Black Krim is a heirloom thought to come from Crimea. It has dark red-purple fruit and a savoury, slightly smoky flavour.
Mortgage Lifter is a large, old heirloom valued for its size and classic tomato taste.
Kellogg’s Breakfast is a large orange-yellow heirloom. It can weigh a pound or more and is often described as sweet and fruity, with a mild acidity.
Some gardeners in online groups recommend a classic French beefsteak, Rouge de Marmande, for hot summers. It is a good example of a heirloom beefsteak that suits warm weather.
Hybrid beefsteaks
Big Beef and Big Beef Plus are widely grown indeterminate hybrids. They produce large, classic slicing tomatoes and are a common choice for gardeners who want a reliable crop. Check the seed packet for the disease resistance codes listed for each variety, since these differ from one variety to another. For blight in particular, see blight-resistant tomato varieties.
Hybrid seed does not come true when you save it, so you will need to buy fresh seed each year if you want the same plant.
Heirloom or hybrid? The trade-offs
Heirlooms are often chosen for flavour and variety, and the seed can be saved and passed on. They can be less uniform and more prone to some diseases.
Hybrids are often bred for uniform fruit, steady yields and disease resistance. They can be less interesting in flavour, depending on the variety. Neither is always better. Decide what matters most to you before you buy.
Choosing by what matters most
- Flavour: Cherokee Purple, Brandywine and Black Krim are often recommended
- Sweet, mild fruit: Kellogg’s Breakfast
- Classic large slices: Mortgage Lifter
- Steady cropping and disease resistance: Big Beef and Big Beef Plus. Check the resistance codes on the packet
- Hot summers: Rouge de Marmande, as some gardeners suggest
Growing beefsteaks well
Start seed indoors early, because beefsteaks need a long season. Plant out after the last frost, once the soil has warmed up.
Give plants strong stakes, cages or a trellis from the day you plant. Heavy fruit can snap a plant that is not supported. Remove side shoots (suckers) regularly and keep a few main stems.
Water steadily. Uneven watering can cause cracking and blossom end rot, which shows as a dark, sunken patch at the base of the fruit. Mulch helps keep the soil moisture steady. Avoid too much nitrogen fertiliser, which gives leafy plants with less fruit.
For more on a specific variety, see our guide to heirloom tomato varieties.
Big fruit and cool summers
Big, heavy beefsteaks usually take longer to ripen than smaller types. In a cool summer, a beefsteak may not ripen fully before the weather turns. See will a green tomato ripen if you pick it. If you garden somewhere cool, choose a smaller variety or a fast-maturing hybrid. Our guide to the best tomato varieties for the UK climate covers options for cooler summers.
For an overview of every tomato in this series, see tomato varieties A to Z.