Varieties

What are the 10 best tasting tomatoes?

The 10 best-tasting tomatoes in grower and seed-company lists, from Brandywine and Cherokee Purple to Sungold and Yellow Pear, with honourable mentions.

On this page
  1. What makes a tomato taste good?
  2. The 10 best-tasting tomatoes
  3. Honourable mentions
  4. Getting the best flavour from your tomatoes

There is no official ranking for flavour, and tastes differ. But the same varieties come up again and again in grower and seed-company lists, so the ten below are the ones most often named as the best-tasting. They are grouped by type, and each note explains what the flavour is like.

What makes a tomato taste good?

Flavour comes from a balance of sugars and acids, with aroma and texture adding to it. Juicy flesh spreads flavour across the mouth, and a thin skin avoids a tough mouthful. Many tomatoes lose flavour if they are picked too early, so most of the taste develops on the vine. See harvesting and using homegrown tomatoes.

Growing conditions matter too. Plenty of sun and steady watering help a plant build up sugars and acids in the fruit. Uneven watering, by contrast, can cause the fruit to split. See why tomatoes split.

The 10 best-tasting tomatoes

Brandywine

Brandywine is a classic pink heirloom beefsteak with a sweet, rich and tangy flavour. Many growers describe it as winey. It is often used as a reference point for flavour. For more on growing it, see our Brandywine growing guide.

Cherokee Purple

Cherokee Purple has dusky purple-red fruit and a rich, deep, slightly smoky flavour. Many gardeners rank it at the top for taste, but it can be less productive than other varieties. Our beefsteak guide compares it with other large types.

Black Krim

Black Krim is a dark reddish-purple heirloom with a savoury, smoky taste. It is thought to come from Crimea. Some growers put it alongside Cherokee Purple as one of their favourite dark tomatoes.

Paul Robeson

Paul Robeson is a dark, burgundy beefsteak with bold, earthy sweetness. Seed companies describe its flavour as excellent, and note that it has an attractive, clean shape.

Kellogg’s Breakfast

Kellogg’s Breakfast is a large orange heirloom beefsteak. Its flavour is sweet and fruity, and the flesh is juicy but meaty. Seed companies often praise it as one of the best large orange tomatoes. It can take longer to ripen than smaller types because of its size.

Eva Purple Ball

Eva Purple Ball is a globe-shaped heirloom with a pinkish-purple skin and a mottled look. Its flesh is juicy and sweet, with a little zip at the finish. Some seed companies describe it as resistant to several diseases, so check the packet for details.

Italian Heirloom

Italian Heirloom is an oxheart-style tomato that sits between a slicer and a paste tomato. It is meaty and rich, with few seeds, so it works well in sandwiches and in sauce. Our guide to oxheart tomatoes explains how to grow this type.

Sungold

Sungold is a hybrid orange cherry tomato known for very high sweetness. Its candy-like flavour makes it a favourite with children and cherry fans. It can split if the water is uneven. Because it is a hybrid, seed saved from it will not come true, so you will need to buy fresh seed each year.

Yellow Pear

Yellow Pear is a small, pear-shaped yellow cherry tomato with a mild, sweet and slightly tangy flavour. It is popular for snacking and salads, and it suits small gardens.

Black Cherry

Black Cherry is a small, dark cherry tomato with a rich, sweet flavour. It is often described as a smaller relative of Cherokee Purple, with similar depth. For more small types, see our best cherry tomato varieties.

Honourable mentions

  • 1884 is a large pink heirloom with a deep, old-fashioned flavour that some seed companies rate highly.
  • Carbon is a dark heirloom with rich, smoky notes.
  • Anna Russian is an early heirloom that tastes rich and sweet. It is a good choice in short seasons, when many big-flavoured varieties are still too slow to ripen.
  • Big Rainbow is a bi-coloured beefsteak that is often described as sweet and mild.
  • Midnight Roma is a paste tomato that is praised for cooking more than for eating raw. Our guide to the best tomatoes for sauce covers paste types.
  • Mortgage Lifter is a large, old heirloom with a classic slicing flavour. It can get very tall, so give it strong support.

Getting the best flavour from your tomatoes

  • Pick when fully ripe. Fruit picked green rarely develops its full flavour. See will a green tomato ripen if you pick it.
  • Keep watering steady. Even moisture reduces splitting and helps the fruit develop good flavour.
  • Give plenty of sun. Warm, sunny conditions help the plant build up sugars and acids.
  • Do not refrigerate ripe tomatoes. Cold storage dulls flavour. See how to store fresh tomatoes. Keep them at room temperature and eat them within a few days.

Taste is personal, so try two or three of these varieties side by side in your own garden. What counts as the best depends on whether you want sweet, rich or tangy fruit.

The complete guide to varieties

Tomato Varieties A to Z
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →