Varieties

Best Tomatoes for Sauce: Paste and Plum Varieties

The best tomatoes for sauce: paste and plum types such as Roma and San Marzano, with heirloom and cherry options, growing tips and safe canning.

On this page
  1. Why paste tomatoes make the best sauce
  2. Top varieties for sauce
  3. Other varieties home cooks and gardeners recommend
  4. Cherry and grape tomatoes for quick sauce
  5. Determinate or indeterminate: which suits sauce?
  6. Growing tomatoes for sauce
  7. Harvesting and preparing tomatoes
  8. Canning sauce safely
  9. Storing fresh sauce

Making your own tomato sauce is one of the best reasons to grow tomatoes. The variety makes a real difference. Meaty fruit with few seeds and less juice cooks down into a thick, rich sauce in less time. Juicy, seedy types need longer simmering and give a looser result.

Why paste tomatoes make the best sauce

Paste and plum tomatoes have firm, meaty flesh, less water and fewer seeds than round slicing types. Less water means less time spent reducing the sauce, and fewer seeds mean less to strain out. For passata, marinara and tomato paste, a paste or plum type is the usual choice. For fresh salsa, see growing tomatoes for salsa.

Top varieties for sauce

Roma is the everyday paste tomato. It is easy to find, meaty and low in moisture. Many Roma types are determinate, so most of the crop ripens together, which suits one big batch of sauce.

San Marzano is a plum-type heirloom from Italy, valued for its sweet, tangy flavour and thin skin. It is a favourite for pasta and pizza sauce. Canned San Marzano with the protected DOP label comes from a designated area in Italy, so look for that label if you want the traditional product. Growth habit varies between seed sources, so check the packet.

Amish Paste is a large, meaty heirloom with few seeds and a rich flavour. It suits sauces and roasting. It is a vigorous plant that needs stakes or cages and a long growing season.

Other varieties home cooks and gardeners recommend

Gardeners in online discussions name other sauce and canning tomatoes, including Opalka, Ukrainian Purple, Juliet and Rutgers. Opinions vary. Many gardeners say the best sauce tomato is the one that grows well and crops well where they live, so it is worth trying one or two of these alongside the classic paste types.

Cherry and grape tomatoes for quick sauce

Cherry and grape tomatoes are not classic sauce tomatoes, but they make quick, sweet sauces, especially when roasted until the skins blister. Their small size means more skin and seed to deal with, and they can take longer to break down. Passing the cooked sauce through a sieve gives a smoother result. For more on small types, see our guide to the best cherry tomato varieties for taste and yield.

Determinate or indeterminate: which suits sauce?

Determinate tomatoes grow to a set size and ripen most of their fruit within a short window. That suits bulk sauce-making, when you want a large batch from a single picking. Indeterminate tomatoes keep growing and fruiting through the season, so you pick a few at a time. Both can make excellent sauce. Choose based on how much you want to process at once and how much space and support you have.

Growing tomatoes for sauce

Start seed indoors and plant out once frost has passed and the weather has warmed. Tomatoes need full sun, well-drained soil and steady watering. Support the plants with stakes or cages from the start. Feed them as they begin to fruit, but avoid too much nitrogen, which gives leaves at the expense of fruit.

Harvesting and preparing tomatoes

Pick tomatoes when they are fully ripe. Look for deep, even colour, slight softness and fruit that comes away from the vine easily. See harvesting and using homegrown tomatoes. Wash them, remove the stalk ends and cut out any bruised or cracked parts.

To peel tomatoes, score a small cross in the base, dip them briefly in boiling water, then slip off the skins. Or skip peeling and pass the cooked tomatoes through a sieve or food mill, which removes most skins and seeds. Simmer with onion, garlic and herbs, then cook the sauce down until it is as thick as you like.

Canning sauce safely

If you plan to can your sauce, follow a tested recipe from a reputable source, such as the USDA National Center for Home Food Preservation, and follow it exactly. Tomatoes are borderline acidic, and ripeness alone does not make them safe for water-bath canning. Most tested recipes add bottled lemon juice or citric acid. Do not change the proportions of tomatoes to other ingredients.

Storing fresh sauce

Cool the sauce quickly, refrigerate it and use it within a few days. For longer storage, freeze it in portions, which keeps it for several months. See how to freeze tomatoes.

The complete guide to varieties

Tomato Varieties A to Z
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →